Comelit 3460HEV vs Ubiquiti UA-G3-INTERCOM: Specification Comparison
Both the Comelit 3460HEV and the Ubiquiti UA-G3-INTERCOM are PoE-powered wall-mount door-station intercoms designed for building entry control — the same general product class a security integrator or IT buyer would evaluate side by side. The 3460HEV targets emergency-call scenarios within the Comelit ViP ecosystem, while the UA-G3-INTERCOM is a general-purpose access-control intercom anchored to the Ubiquiti UniFi platform. This comparison covers environmental and build specs, power and connectivity, and platform integration.
In This Guide
- Which unit is better suited for harsh outdoor or demanding physical environments?
- How do the two units compare on power requirements and network connectivity?
- Which platform ecosystem does each unit require, and how does that affect deployment flexibility?
- Which should you choose: the 3460HEV or the UA-G3-INTERCOM?
- Side-by-Side Specs
- FAQ
Which unit is better suited for harsh outdoor or demanding physical environments?
The UA-G3-INTERCOM carries an IP65 ingress-protection rating and is rated for operation from −30°C to 60°C, making it explicitly specified for outdoor exposure including cold climates. Its enclosure combines aluminum alloy, UV-stabilized polycarbonate, and glass, with a powder-coated stainless steel mount bracket — materials chosen for UV and corrosion resistance. It holds CE, FCC, IC, UL 294, and CAN/ULC-60839-11-1 certifications.
The 3460HEV spec set does not state an IP ingress rating or an operating temperature range. Its housing is described as stainless steel with a white finish, and the product is noted to include Braille-marked buttons for ADA accessibility compliance. No environmental certifications are listed in the provided specs. Buyers installing in uncontrolled or outdoor environments cannot confirm suitability from the available 3460HEV data alone.
How do the two units compare on power requirements and network connectivity?
Both devices draw power over a single RJ45 Ethernet run, eliminating dedicated AC power wiring — a meaningful installation advantage in retrofit scenarios. The 3460HEV specifies PoE 802.3af (nominally up to 15.4 W budget). The UA-G3-INTERCOM specifies 48 V DC PoE at 13 W actual consumption; the spec also references 802.3af in one field, but the stated 48 V DC and 13 W draw should be verified against the injector or switch port budget at design time.
The UA-G3-INTERCOM adds a Gigabit-speed RJ45 port, NFC credential support (Forum tag types T1T through T5T), PIN code entry, and mobile app unlock — three distinct credential modalities over a single connection. The 3460HEV's credential and reader capabilities are not detailed in the provided specs beyond its role as a video entry panel within the Comelit ViP system. Video compression for the 3460HEV is H.264 at 4 MP (2560×1440); the UA-G3-INTERCOM's video resolution and compression standard are not stated in the provided specs.
Which platform ecosystem does each unit require, and how does that affect deployment flexibility?
The 3460HEV is specified for integration with Comelit video entry and access control systems, specifically the Comelit ViP system. This means the device is designed as a component within a proprietary Comelit architecture; buyers must confirm compatibility with any third-party VMS or access-control head-end independently, as the specs do not list open-standard VMS compatibility beyond the ViP system.
The UA-G3-INTERCOM is managed exclusively through the Ubiquiti UniFi platform, including the UniFi mobile app. Management options listed are UniFi platform, mobile app, and PIN authentication. It carries NDAA compliance certification, which is a procurement requirement for U.S. federal and certain state/local government projects. The 3460HEV specs do not reference NDAA compliance. Sites already running UniFi network infrastructure can integrate the UA-G3-INTERCOM without adding a separate access-control server, while Comelit ViP deployments require Comelit head-end hardware or software.
Which should you choose: the 3460HEV or the UA-G3-INTERCOM?
Our take: The UA-G3-INTERCOM is the stronger choice when the installation requires confirmed outdoor environmental ratings, multi-credential access control, or NDAA-compliant hardware. It carries an IP65 rating and a −30°C to 60°C operating range that the 3460HEV does not document; supports NFC (T1T–T5T), PIN, and mobile unlock where the 3460HEV lists no credential modalities beyond its emergency-call function; and holds UL 294 plus NDAA compliance certifications absent from the 3460HEV spec set. Conversely, the 3460HEV is the correct choice for sites standardized on the Comelit ViP system needing a dedicated emergency-call video station: its 4 MP (2560×1440) H.264 resolution and ADA-compliant Braille button are explicitly specified, while the UA-G3-INTERCOM's camera resolution is not stated. Platform lock is the decisive qualifier — neither unit operates meaningfully outside its native ecosystem.
Side-by-Side Comparison
Spec-for-spec, from manufacturer data.
| Specification | Comelit 3460HEV | Ubiquiti UA-G3-INTERCOM |
|---|---|---|
| Device Class | Video Entry Panel (Emergency) | Intercom Terminal (Door Entry) |
| Form Factor | Entry Panel | Intercom Terminal |
| Mount Type | Wall | Wall (gooseneck pedestal adapter included) |
| IP Rating | — | IP65 |
| Operating Temperature | — | −30°C to 60°C (device); −25°C to 60°C (display) |
| Power Input | PoE 802.3af | PoE 48V DC, 13W |
| Network Port Speed | — | Gigabit Ethernet |
| Video Resolution | 4MP (2560×1440) | — |
| Video Compression | H.264 | — |
| Credential Modalities | — | NFC (T1T–T5T), PIN, Mobile App |
| Management Platform | Comelit ViP System | Ubiquiti UniFi Platform |
| Enclosure Material | Stainless Steel | Aluminum alloy, UV polycarbonate, glass |
| ADA / Accessibility | Braille-marked button | — |
| NDAA Compliant | — | Yes |
| Certifications | — | CE, FCC, IC, UL 294, CAN/ULC-60839-11-1 |
| Warranty | 2-Year | Manufacturer Warranty (duration not specified) |
Frequently Asked Questions
Which should you choose: the 3460HEV or the UA-G3-INTERCOM?
The UA-G3-INTERCOM is the stronger choice when the installation requires confirmed outdoor environmental ratings, multi-credential access control, or NDAA-compliant hardware. It carries an IP65 rating and a −30°C to 60°C operating range that the 3460HEV does not document; supports NFC (T1T–T5T), PIN, and mobile unlock where the 3460HEV lists no credential modalities beyond its emergency-call function; and holds UL 294 plus NDAA compliance certifications absent from the 3460HEV spec set. Conversely, the 3460HEV is the correct choice for sites standardized on the Comelit ViP system needing a dedicated emergency-call video station: its 4 MP (2560×1440) H.264 resolution and ADA-compliant Braille button are explicitly specified, while the UA-G3-INTERCOM's camera resolution is not stated. Platform lock is the decisive qualifier — neither unit operates meaningfully outside its native ecosystem.
Can either the 3460HEV or UA-G3-INTERCOM be installed outdoors in a cold climate?
The UA-G3-INTERCOM is rated IP65 and specified for −30°C to 60°C operation, making it suitable for cold outdoor environments per its published specs. The 3460HEV does not state an IP rating or operating temperature range in the provided specifications, so outdoor suitability cannot be confirmed from available data.
Does the UA-G3-INTERCOM or the 3460HEV support keycard or fob credentials?
The UA-G3-INTERCOM supports NFC Forum tag types T1T through T5T, PIN code, and mobile app unlock — covering common contactless credential formats. The 3460HEV's provided specs do not list any credential reader capability; it is described as a video entry panel for emergency calls within the Comelit ViP system.
Which unit is required for a U.S. government or federally funded project with NDAA restrictions?
The UA-G3-INTERCOM is listed as NDAA-compliant in its specifications. The 3460HEV specs do not reference NDAA compliance. For projects subject to NDAA Section 889 procurement restrictions, the UA-G3-INTERCOM is the only option of these two with a documented compliance claim.
More Intercom Comparisons
- Ubiquiti UA-G3-INTERCOM vs SDC IPDSE
- Ubiquiti UA-G3-INTERCOM vs Comelit TP6842
- Ubiquiti UA-G3-INTERCOM vs ACTi Q950
- Axis 03448-001 vs Axis 02892-001
- Comelit TP6842 vs ACTi Q950
- Comelit TP6842 vs Comelit 3460HEV
Intercom Buying Guides
Get a Second Opinion on Your Camera Choice
Share your site layout, coverage goals, and budget. Our team will validate the camera selection, flag anything we would change, and recommend products that match the use case.