HID 40TKS-00-000000 vs Comelit 909020113: Specification Comparison
Both the HID 40TKS-00-000000 SIGNO 40 and the Comelit 909020113 GS3-MT are wall-mounted proximity access control readers designed for credential-based entry management in commercial and light-industrial environments. Both output Wiegand protocol signals and support indoor/outdoor deployment, placing them in the same general product class. The comparison focuses on the three dimensions most critical to an installer or IT buyer evaluating proximity readers: credential compatibility and protocol output; power delivery and physical installation; and environmental rating, form factor, and integration flexibility.
In This Guide
- Which reader supports a broader range of credentials and protocol outputs?
- How do the two readers differ in power delivery and wiring installation?
- Which reader is better suited for harsh environments and broader panel integration?
- Which should you choose: the 40TKS-00-000000 or the 909020113?
- Side-by-Side Specs
- FAQ
Which reader supports a broader range of credentials and protocol outputs?
The HID 40TKS-00-000000 is specified as a Wiegand 32-bit MSB output reader accepting EM 4100/4102 proximity cards (32-bit EM-compatible format). Its NFC/BLE field references SEOS profile, Smart profile, and Standard, suggesting multi-technology capability beyond bare EM cards, though the primary marketed credential is the 32-bit EM card. Protocol output is fixed: Wiegand 32-bit MSB.
The Comelit 909020113 is described as supporting PAC OPS™, KeyPAC, and third-party Wiegand credentials on a single reader, indicating a multi-format credential platform. Its Wiegand protocol compatibility is confirmed for downstream panel integration. Encryption is noted as standard-level when paired with PAC 512 controllers, adding a configurable tamper and line-tamper function not mentioned in the HID spec.
For sites running legacy EM badge stock exclusively, the HID reader's EM 4100/4102 acceptance is directly confirmed. For mixed-credential environments—particularly PAC ecosystem deployments—the Comelit 909020113's multi-format support and PAC 512 integration path is the more explicitly documented option.
How do the two readers differ in power delivery and wiring installation?
The HID 40TKS-00-000000 is powered by 12VDC (standard) over a wired connection, with flush-mount terminal block and pigtail wiring options noted. This is conventional low-voltage wiring requiring a separate power run from the panel or a local 12VDC supply. No PoE capability is specified.
The Comelit 909020113 is powered via PoE (802.3af), consolidating power and data on a single Cat cable run to an 802.3af-capable switch or injector. The spec card notes a minimum 13W per port requirement. This single-cable architecture can reduce conduit runs and installation labor on IP-based access control deployments.
The power architecture is a meaningful differentiator: the HID unit suits legacy panel-centric wiring plants where 12VDC homerun cabling is already in place. The Comelit unit suits IP-networked access control architectures where PoE infrastructure is available and single-cable installation is preferred. Neither unit is wireless; both require a physical cable run.
Which reader is better suited for harsh environments and broader panel integration?
The HID 40TKS-00-000000 is rated for indoor/outdoor use. No specific IP or IK ingress-protection rating is published in the provided spec data. Finish is Black/Silver with a standard-profile surface-mount form factor. Feedback is provided via red LED, green flash, and an integrated buzzer.
The Comelit 909020113 carries an IP65 rating per the provided specs, confirming dust-tight and water-jet-resistant performance per IEC 60529. Housing material is UL-rated polycarbonate. Weight is 0.290 kg / 0.639 lb. Dimensions are 89 × 115 × 28 mm. Audio/visual feedback includes an audible sounder and red/green LEDs. An integral tamper circuit and mounting plate are included in the package.
The Comelit reader's IP65 rating is a verifiable environmental benchmark absent from the HID spec as provided. For exposed outdoor locations, wet areas, or installations where an IP rating is a contractual or code requirement, the Comelit 909020113 has a documented advantage. The HID unit lists indoor/outdoor suitability but without a confirmed IP rating in the available data.
Which should you choose: the 40TKS-00-000000 or the 909020113?
Our take: The Comelit 909020113 is the stronger choice when the installation runs on an IP/PoE network infrastructure, requires a documented IP65 weatherproofing rating, or must support mixed PAC-ecosystem credentials including PAC OPS™ and KeyPAC alongside standard Wiegand. Concrete spec deltas: the 909020113 carries a confirmed IP65 rating versus no IP rating published for the 40TKS-00-000000; it draws power via PoE 802.3af (single Cat cable, 13W minimum) versus the HID's 12VDC wired supply requiring a separate power run; and it explicitly supports multiple credential formats (PAC OPS™, KeyPAC, third-party Wiegand) versus the HID's primary EM 4100/4102 32-bit credential focus. Conversely, the HID 40TKS-00-000000 is the appropriate choice for legacy panel environments already wired for 12VDC with existing EM card badge stock, where Wiegand 32-bit MSB direct panel integration is required and no PoE infrastructure exists.
Side-by-Side Comparison
Spec-for-spec, from manufacturer data.
| Specification | HID 40TKS-00-000000 | Comelit 909020113 |
|---|---|---|
| Product Type | Proximity/RFID Access Control Reader | Proximity/RFID Access Control Reader |
| SKU | 40TKS-00-000000 | 909020113 |
| Power Supply | 12VDC (wired) | PoE 802.3af (single cable, 13W min) |
| Protocol Output | Wiegand 32-bit MSB | Wiegand (protocol compatible) |
| Supported Credentials | EM 4100/4102 (32-bit EM card); SEOS/Smart/Standard noted | PAC OPS™, KeyPAC, third-party Wiegand |
| IP / Ingress Rating | Not specified in provided data | IP65 |
| Housing Material | Not specified in provided data | UL-rated Polycarbonate |
| Housing Color / Finish | Black/Silver | White |
| Dimensions | 80 x 121.5 x 19.5 in (as listed; verify units) | 89 x 115 x 28 mm / 3.50 x 4.53 x 1.10 in |
| Weight | Not specified in provided data | 0.290 kg / 0.639 lb |
| Environment | Indoor / Outdoor | IP65 Indoor/Outdoor weatherresistant |
| Mount Type | Wall / Surface-mount standard profile | Wall |
| Wiring Options | Terminal block and pigtail | Single Cat cable (PoE) |
| Audio/Visual Feedback | Red LED, Green Flash, Integrated Buzzer | Audible Sounder, Red/Green LEDs |
| Tamper Protection | Not specified in provided data | Integral tamper circuit; line tamper configurable with PAC 512 |
| Warranty | 2-Year | 2-Year |
Frequently Asked Questions
Which should you choose: the 40TKS-00-000000 or the 909020113?
The Comelit 909020113 is the stronger choice when the installation runs on an IP/PoE network infrastructure, requires a documented IP65 weatherproofing rating, or must support mixed PAC-ecosystem credentials including PAC OPS™ and KeyPAC alongside standard Wiegand. Concrete spec deltas: the 909020113 carries a confirmed IP65 rating versus no IP rating published for the 40TKS-00-000000; it draws power via PoE 802.3af (single Cat cable, 13W minimum) versus the HID's 12VDC wired supply requiring a separate power run; and it explicitly supports multiple credential formats (PAC OPS™, KeyPAC, third-party Wiegand) versus the HID's primary EM 4100/4102 32-bit credential focus. Conversely, the HID 40TKS-00-000000 is the appropriate choice for legacy panel environments already wired for 12VDC with existing EM card badge stock, where Wiegand 32-bit MSB direct panel integration is required and no PoE infrastructure exists.
Is the HID 40TKS-00-000000 or the Comelit 909020113 easier to wire into an existing access control panel?
The HID 40TKS-00-000000 outputs Wiegand 32-bit MSB directly and connects via terminal block or pigtail wiring on 12VDC—matching the wiring plant of most legacy panels without additional hardware. The Comelit 909020113 is also Wiegand-compatible for panel output but requires an 802.3af PoE switch or injector (13W minimum per port) on the power side, which adds a network infrastructure dependency not present with the HID unit.
Which reader is rated for exposed outdoor use in wet or dusty conditions?
The Comelit 909020113 specifies an IP65 rating, meaning it is dust-tight and protected against water jets per IEC 60529. The HID 40TKS-00-000000 is listed as suitable for indoor/outdoor environments, but no specific IP ingress-protection rating is provided in the available spec data. For installations where a contractual or code-mandated IP rating is required, the Comelit 909020113 has a documented specification; the HID unit does not.
Can either reader work with existing proximity card badge stock from other manufacturers?
The HID 40TKS-00-000000 accepts EM 4100/4102 proximity cards (32-bit EM-compatible format), so existing EM-format badge stock can be reused during a migration. The Comelit 909020113 supports PAC OPS™, KeyPAC, and third-party Wiegand credentials, making it compatible with a broader range of credential types in mixed-technology environments. Neither reader's spec confirms support for HID iCLASS or MIFARE credentials in the data provided.
More Access Control Reader Comparisons
- HID 5365EGP00 vs Comelit 909020116
- HID 5365EGP00 vs Speco Technologies AP500HA
- HID 5365EGP00 vs Comelit 909020113
- HID 5365EGP00 vs HID 20NKS-00-000000
- HID 5365EGP00 vs HID 40NKS-00-000000
- Comelit 909020116 vs Speco Technologies AP500HA
Access Control Reader Buying Guides
Get a Second Opinion on Your Camera Choice
Share your site layout, coverage goals, and budget. Our team will validate the camera selection, flag anything we would change, and recommend products that match the use case.